Understanding UK Shareholders Agreements: Key Elements and Benefits Explained

Shareholders’ agreements are crucial cogs in the legal ecosystem in which UK businesses operate. However, what are the essentials of a robust agreement? Why should your business prioritise a bespoke agreement? And what happens in the absence of one? 

In this article, we dive into shareholders' agreements, answering key FAQs such as their benefits, their strengths, and their most common components. 

In this article, we'll cover,

• What is a shareholders' agreement?
• Do I need a shareholders' agreement?
• What are the benefits of having a shareholders' agreement in the UK?
• How to draft a shareholders’ agreement
• What are reserved matters in a shareholders' agreement?
• How to protect minority shareholders in shareholder agreements
• Can a shareholders' agreement be amended?
• Can a shareholders’ agreement override articles?
• Do all shareholders have to sign a shareholders’ agreement?

What is a shareholders’ agreement?

A shareholders' agreement defines how a business will operate and interact with its shareholders. You can think of it as a bespoke contract that ensures every stakeholder knows their role and expectations.

When securing investment, a shareholders’ agreement can quickly become critical, as it reassures investors of their rights and returns, how their investments will be managed, expectations on dividends, and details on exit strategies. This agreement, in many ways, acts as a safeguard for investors to protect their interests and reduce potential disputes. 

What is the purpose of a shareholders' agreement?

A shareholders' agreement will define shareholder responsibilities, delineate their rights, and set down the processes for addressing key matters, such as decision-making and dispute resolution. This is crucial when it comes to avoiding misunderstandings by setting a clear means of managing relationships and protecting both individual and collective investments in the company. 

The purpose of a shareholders' agreement is multifaceted, but ultimately, it organises the relationship among shareholders to facilitate the smooth operation of the business. By clearly outlining rights, responsibilities, and processes, you can aim to prevent disagreements and disputes, with frameworks in place to handle potential conflicts. 

Do I need a shareholders' agreement?

While there's no legal requirement to have a shareholders' agreement in the UK, it's strongly recommended for any company with more than one shareholder. 

However, what happens when you park a shareholders' agreement? Without one, you can quickly find yourself in a situation where interests clash and there’s no predetermined resolution process in place. For example, let's say there's a disagreement about dividend payments or the direction of the business itself. A well-drafted shareholders' agreement would have cut out the guesswork, with a structured outline for these disagreements. However, in the absence of the agreement, you're instead faced with a quagmire of complications.

It's also worth noting the importance of shareholders' agreements when it comes to protecting minority shareholders. A shareholders' agreement can provide provisions that protect minority shareholders from being outvoted or pushed aside in important company decisions. 

How to protect minority shareholders in shareholder agreements 

Minority shareholders, as a result of having a smaller portion of the company's shares, can find themselves in a vulnerable position as the business grows. Ensuring their rights and interests are protected is crucial to maintaining a fair shareholder dynamic overall. Below are some proactive tips to help protect minority shareholders in your agreements.

Tag-along rights

This clause is essential if a majority shareholder wants to sell their shares to an external party. Tag-along rights stipulate that minority shareholders are also offered the opportunity to sell their shares on the same terms, to avoid being left behind in a control shift.

Pre-emptive rights

As a preventive measure against dilution, pre-emptive rights allow minority shareholders to buy additional shares before the company offers them to other potential shareholders. This protection helps maintain their ownership percentage.

Reserved matters

Reserved matters are decisions that cannot be made without the approval of all or a specified percentage of shareholders, including those in the minority. This might include major company decisions such as mergers, asset sales, or changes to the Articles of Association.

Access to information

Providing minority shareholders with the right to access financial reports, meeting minutes, and other relevant documents can empower them to make informed decisions while promoting a sense of transparency throughout the business.

By incorporating these protections, you can ensure a fair environment for all stakeholders involved. Keep in mind that a well-drafted shareholders' agreement not only shields minority shareholders but also contributes to the overall health and stability of your company.

Which brings us to...

What are the benefits of having a shareholders' agreement in the UK?

A shareholders' agreement is an invaluable tool, particularly in the UK, providing several benefits that contribute to the smooth running of your business. Let's take these benefits one by one.

Clarity and certainty

One of the most significant advantages is the clarity these agreements offer. By clearly outlining the rights and obligations of each shareholder, misunderstandings are minimised, with a road for resolution in the event of a disagreement.

Dispute resolution

Disputes are the last thing any business or shareholder wants, but they're an unfortunate part of the day-to-day running of a company. With this in mind, having a predefined process for resolving disputes is important. Disagreements among shareholders can sometimes escalate, potentially harming your business in the process. However, with a well-drafted agreement to hand, you can streamline a solution and avoid a costly legal battle at the same time.

Protection of interests

Shareholders' agreements, as we've previously touched on, also ensure that minority interests are protected. They include specific clauses that prevent unfair treatment and protect the investment of all shareholders, regardless of their holding size. 

Flexibility

Shareholder agreements offer the flexibility to tailor terms according to the specific needs and goals of the shareholders and the company. While Articles of Association provide a legal framework for managing a company, a shareholders' agreement can expand on these rules and incorporate more detailed arrangements. 

How to draft a shareholders' agreement

When drafting your shareholders’ agreement, working with a UK solicitor who is intimately aware of your business and its long-term ambitions can be invaluable. To draft your agreement, you'll need a clear understanding of your company's needs and its legal framework, with a focus on creating an agreement that caters to the interests of all parties involved. Let's explore a few best practice steps towards creating a fit-for-purpose document.

Carefully consider shareholder rights

It might seem common sense, or obvious, but a granular consideration of shareholder rights is critical to crafting the right document for your business. You'll want to think clearly about rights, obligations, and, importantly, the circumstances under which these might change. Pay attention to voting rights, information rights, and entitlement to dividends.

Focus on wide-ranging compliance

Your shareholders' agreement will operate in a broader legal ecosystem, from the Companies Act 2006, through to your company's own legal frameworks - such as the Articles of Association. Therefore, the legal integrity of your document will need to be robust, so make sure it complements both the external and internal legal frameworks your business operates. 

Park the templates

The World Wide Web is densely populated with shareholders' agreement templates, and while they can be useful when it comes to understanding the "bones" of an agreement, they're not a one-size-fits-all solution. Your shareholders' agreement, correctly designed, can be an asset in your arsenal. However, to achieve this, you'll need to ensure it aligns closely with your business, your shareholders' interests, and your long-term goals overall. 

What are reserved matters in a shareholders' agreement?

Reserved matters are designed to ensure significant company decisions are subject to shareholder approval, rather than being left solely to the board of directors. These matters usually require a higher threshold of approval, often a supermajority or unanimity among shareholders, depending on the terms specified in the agreement. 

By requiring shareholder consent for certain decisions, reserved matters can ensure that management actions continue to align with shareholder interests. This is particularly important in protecting minority shareholders, for example, by giving them a voice in major company changes that could otherwise be decided by a majority vote. 

Common examples of reserved matters include:

• Significant capital expenditures or investments beyond a certain amount
• Changes to the company’s Articles
• Issuance of new shares, or modifications to share rights
• Entering into or terminating large contracts
• Appointment or removal of directors
• Modification of the business, including mergers, acquisitions, or dissolutions

Can a shareholders' agreement be amended?

In short, yes! Your shareholders' agreement is designed to adapt to the evolving needs of your business, such as changes in share ownership, new business directions, or updated legal requirements. 

However, amendments to a shareholders' agreement will require the mutual consent of all parties involved. This means that any change, be it adding, removing, or modifying clauses, will need to be agreed upon collectively by shareholders. 

To amend the agreement, shareholders usually need to follow procedures specified within the current agreement. This might involve formal meetings or a documented resolution. Some agreements might outline specific approval thresholds for amendments, which you'll need to closely follow.

While the process of amending a shareholders' agreement might seem daunting, it's core to keeping your agreement bespoke to your business. With this in mind, working with a trusted UK lawyer can help ensure amendments are legally sound while remaining beneficial to all parties. 

Can a shareholders' agreement override articles? 

A common shareholder agreement question revolves around Articles of Association, and whether an agreement can really override them. The answer is nuanced. Generally, your Articles of Association will take precedence as the constitution of your company. However, this is not to say that there aren't circumstances where your shareholders’ agreement can override your Articles. For example, if a supremacy clause exists.

However, it's important to remember that this agreement cannot force your company to operate in a way that contradicts its Articles or the Companies Act. While a shareholders' agreement can offer bespoke arrangements tailored to shareholders' needs, it must not direct the company to breach its formal constitution. For example, if the Articles stipulate certain procedures for appointing directors, a shareholders' agreement suggesting a different method might not be viable.

Do all shareholders have to sign a shareholders' agreement? 

While it is generally recommended that all shareholders sign the agreement, it's not necessarily required. Shareholders' agreements can be quite flexible, with tailoring to include some or all shareholders, depending on the needs and intentions of the parties involved. 

For example, in scenarios where there are multiple classes of shares, you might find agreements that are limited to specific classes or groups. This could happen in family-owned businesses where only family members are part of a shareholders' agreement, or in companies where there’s a separation of roles between management and investment shareholders. Similarly, there are instances when a new shareholder might not automatically become a party to an existing agreement unless they explicitly agree to it. 

In conclusion

Shareholders' agreements in the UK are key to the smooth running and governance of your company. With that in mind, drafting a comprehensive shareholders agreement will involve careful consideration of specific clauses and individual shareholder rights, to ultimately ensure it truly operates to its true strength. 

Exploring shareholders' agreements, or seeking advice on an existing one? Our team of UK lawyers are on hand to help.

‍